For more distant stations with lower incoming
propagation angles (such as ground wave, troposcatter or double hop Es),
the maximum gain of the lowest lobe (when the antenna is pointed at the
horizon) is clearly beneficial. Pointing the antenna at the horizon
to obtain the approximately 18.5 dbd gain from the second vertical lobe
at 12 degrees elevation has also proven advantageous in EME communciations
when the moon is at that particular elevation. In addition, the large
gain in the higher lobes is definitely desirable at this location - surrounding
mountains create a high horizon in certain directions,
totally blocking signals coming in at lower angles.
.
Thanks to VE7BQH for providing the above antenna pattern plots.